For the 2008 Indians, It's 1968 Revisited
Published June 03, 2008
With another lost weekend under their belt, you can almost feel the last ounce of optimism dripping from the entire Cleveland Indians organization. In a season of dispiriting losses, these were just a few more. But given that the Kansas City Royals were on a bit of a tear themselves — 12 straight losses and counting — possibly the only positive from the Indians' trip into Kansas City was that this team might finally have reached rock bottom. If not, then hide the children.
The Indians may not be the most disappointing team in the major leagues this year, but they are on a fast track to the top two. Laying waste to exceptional starting pitching with impunity, the team that was one game from the World Series last year right now can't beat Kansas City. Baseball fortunes can certainly turn quickly and teams can get hot, but seriously does anyone see that in the near term for this team, particularly as presently constituted?
The most frustrating aspect about Version 2008 of the Indians is the unrealized promise of its starting pitching. Done in mostly by a lack of offense this year's Indians ought to be clothed in the vintage uniforms of their 1960s predecessors. In fact, if you want to throw darts and pick a year, the summer of 2008 is taking on the look and feel of the summer of 1968, meaning all pitch and no hit.
Baseball is far different today than in 1968. Most notably, pitching dominated in a way it hasn't since. The mound was higher. There were fewer teams. There was no designated hitter. Ball clubs had to be built to withstand a 10-team race. Before the march to expansion and ultimately three divisions in each league, baseball in 1968 has the American League and the National League. No wild cards, no ALDS, no ALCS.
In '68, the Indians had one of the better pitching staffs in the league, most of which was a holdover from the previous year. Alvin Dark was in his first full season as the Indians' manager, which was not surprising given that the team was coming off what can only be characterized as a miserable season the year before. Despite a pitching rotation that in 1967 featured Sam McDowell, Luis Tiant, Steve Hargan and Sonny Siebert, the Indians finished eighth in the American League at 75-87. The team ERA was 3.25, a figure that would be leading the major leagues right now but was only fifth best in the league then. The far bigger problem is that the Indians couldn't score runs. That didn't change much in 1968.
- For the 2008 Indians, It's 1968 Revisited
- Published: June 03, 2008
- Type: Opinion
- Section: Sports
- Filed Under: Sports: Baseball
- Writer: Gary D. Benz
- Gary D. Benz's BC Writer page
- Gary D. Benz's personal site
- Spread the Word
- Like this article?
- Email this
Save to del.icio.us







Gary,
One of the best write-ups on the Tribe's woes in this disappointing 2008 season. Things could be a little worse. It could be as bad as the '87 Indians, touted as a World Series contender and losing over 100 games. I don't see that happening this year; but as an Indians' fan, I can't hide my disapointment.